Signs you need a new roof
The clearest signs are shingles that are curling, cracking or missing; bald spots where the granules have worn off (and granules piling up in your gutters); leaks in more than one place; daylight or water stains in the attic; a wavy or sagging roofline; and a roof that already has two layers of shingles, which Virginia code says can't take a third. One problem in one spot is often a repair. Several at once usually means it's time to replace.
What to look for
1. Curling or cupping shingles. Edges that turn up or middles that sink mean the shingles are drying out and losing their grip.
2. Missing or cracked shingles. A few after a windstorm can be repaired. Wind is what usually tears shingles off around Richmond. If new ones go missing every storm, the roof is getting brittle.
3. Bald spots and granules in the gutters. The granules protect the shingle from the sun. Dark bald patches on the roof, or gritty granules piling up in your gutters and at the bottom of downspouts, mean the shingles are wearing out.
4. More than one leak. One leak usually has one cause, often a pipe boot or flashing. Several leaks in different places suggest the whole roof is failing. How to trace a leak.
5. Light or stains in the attic. On a sunny day, look for daylight through the roof boards. Dark stains, rusty nail tips or damp insulation mean water is getting in.
6. A wavy or sagging roofline. Waves in the roof can mean the decking underneath has gotten wet and soft. Get this looked at soon.
7. Two layers of shingles already. Look at the edge of the roof from a ladder at the gutter, or ask the inspector. If you see two stacks of shingle edges, someone roofed over the old roof. About 1 in 10 roofs we priced over the past year had that second layer.1 Virginia’s building code doesn’t allow a new roof over one that already has two layers, so the next roof has to start with a full tear-off.2
8. Moss or dark streaks, with other wear. Streaks on their own are usually algae and mostly cosmetic. Combined with the signs above, they’re another hint the roof is aging.
What age tells you, and what it doesn’t
Your house’s age isn’t your roof’s age. About 68% of homes in the City of Richmond were built before 1980, so many are on their second or third roof by now.3 A roof’s real age is on the old contract or permit, if you have it. If you don’t, the signs above tell you more than a date.
What to do next
If you see one or two of these, a repair may be all you need. If you see several, book a free estimate. Houston will photograph what he finds and tell you straight whether it’s a repair or a roof replacement. Want a number first? RoofRead gives you a ballpark for your house in about 30 seconds.
Footnotes
-
BNH Roofing estimates, October 2025 to October 2026: share of shingle roofs we measured and priced whose estimate included a second-layer tear-off. ↩
-
2021 Virginia Residential Code, Section R908.3.1.1: a roof recover isn’t permitted where the existing roof has two or more applications of roof covering. Chapter 9, Roof Assemblies ↩
-
U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2024 1-year estimates, Table B25034 (Year Structure Built). Table B25034 ↩
Common questions
Can I check my roof myself?
From the ground, with binoculars, yes, and from the attic with a flashlight. Please don't climb onto the roof. Most of these signs are visible from the yard or the attic.
My roof is old but doesn't leak. Should I replace it?
Not necessarily. Age alone isn't a reason. Have it inspected: if the shingles still have their granules and lie flat, it may have years left.
Can you just put new shingles over the old ones?
Code allows one layer over another in some cases, but never a third. We tear every roof off down to the deck, because it's the only way to see and fix the wood underneath.